A watchdog report found FEMA “lost visibility” of nearly 40% of shipments.
The Department of Homeland Security Office of Inspector General found that FEMA “lost visibility” or failed to fully track nearly 40% of shipments to Puerto Rico with a value of nearly $257 million in meals, water, blankets and other supplies. Of the nearly 10,000 shipping containers sent to Puerto Rico, 19 were never recovered.
The impact was felt in the long delays in the delivery of supplies. Goods sat under FEMA control on the island, on average, for about 48 days after they were delivered, and shipments of water and food were delayed by about two months, according to the report.
“Given the lost visibility and delayed shipments, FEMA cannot ensure it provided commodities to Puerto Rico disaster survivors as needed to sustain life and alleviate suffering as part of its response and recovery mission,” the report reads.
In a memo responding to the report, FEMA Associate Administrator Cynthia Spishak said the agency produced an excess of 5 million meals and 45 million liters of water, suggesting it was more than local municipalities in Puerto Rico were able to accept.
“The delivery of meals and water that remained in undelivered status skewed the average delivery time calculations,” Spishak wrote in the memo from earlier this month and released in the report.
But in the critical first two months after Maria, local officials from nearly a quarter of municipalities said they did not receive sufficient food and water, and 40% said expiring food caused “significant problems.”
Puerto Rican officials cited in the report also said that many of the food packages were boxes filled with junk food.
Overall, FEMA reported delivering 63.6 million meals of 75.1 million liters of water in response to the historic natural disasters.
While the agency did attempt to expand its ability to track its shipments, the report found that GPS transponders were not working properly after they were attached to containers. The agency had placed an order to double the number of transponders in its supply chain system in September 2017, the same month Maria made landfall.
“The amount of commodities that FEMA lost because of its mismanagement of the distribution process is undeterminable,” the report said.