On Tuesday, voters got in Trump’s face for the first time. On Thursday, they practically gave Biden a hero’s welcome in Scranton, Pa.
For the second time this week, a presidential candidate fielded questions from voters in a town hall setting. But if ABC’s event with President Donald Trump was an icy grilling, CNN’s drive-in conversation with Joe Biden Thursday was more like an affable reunion of old acquaintances.
“Chief, didn’t I meet you when you were chief?” Biden said through a half-smile, pointing at the man preparing to ask him a question. Bill Barrett, a retired police chief who is in his fifth term on city council, wanted to know how Biden will address growing violence in cities and the lack of respect for police and the military.
Barrett confirmed that, yes, they’d met when he was chief. And so it went with several other questioners and Biden during a 75-minute homecoming close by to where the candidate spent his youth.
Trump had few such comfortable moments in his brutal town hall: For his first time as president, regular people got the chance to call him out on his boasting and exaggerations. Biden, by comparison, got a “total pass,” the Trump campaign complained afterward, in a typical lashing of the media. The Democratic nominee made the most of the friendly confines, relaying feel-your-pain anecdotes in mostly grammatical syntax and, until the last half-hour, with high-energy.
The back-to-back town halls helped shape the contours of the upcoming debates in a presidential contest where Biden has maintained a steady lead in battleground states.
Here’s a look at the key moments from Thursday night.
Scranton vs. Park Avenue
Trump has maintained an unshakable appeal among a segment of working-class Americans —a group he used to refer to as the “super elite” (“We got more brains, we got better houses, apartments, we got nicer boats, we’re smarter,” he told supporters in the summer of 2018.). Biden, a product of Scranton, had made some inroads with the cohort, but on Thursday, he used an answer in which he acknowledged his own white privilege to more overtly frame the race between him and Trump as one of class differences.
“I really do view this campaign as a campaign between Scranton and Park Avenue,” Biden said. Turning folksy, Biden said all the people out there who are “busting their necks” — all they want is a fair shot.
“And guys like Trump, who inherited everything, and squandered what they inherited, are the people that I have always had a problem with, not the people who are busting their neck,” Biden added.
But Trump couldn’t care less, Biden said: “All that President Trump could see from Park Avenue is Wall Street. All he thinks about is the stock market.”
It was a direct reference to Trump’s answers on Tuesday, when George Stephanopoulos pressed him on the uneven economy that continues to favor the affluent over working people. “George,” Trump said, “stocks are owned by everybody,” pointing to retirement plans and other investments.
“How many of you all own stock in Scranton?” Biden asked Thursday. “Not a whole lot of people own stock.”
Biden then sounded a more personal note about people who grew up in places like Scranton.
“I don’t trust the president on vaccines,” Biden said. “If [Anthony] Fauci says the vaccine is safe, I’d take the vaccine.”
“Yesterday, 1,200 deaths in the United States. All of Canada had nine,” Biden said. “Last Friday we had 1,000 deaths. All of Canada had zero deaths. This president is doing it all wrong. We need to make a fundamental change in the way we’re moving.”
But Biden vastly overstated what protections could have worked against the virus. He argued that had Trump done his job, everybody would still be alive — not true. “All the people — I’m not making this up,” Biden said, driving the point home. “Just look at the data. Look at the data.”
Calling out Barr
Biden questioned how that equated to taking away freedoms, as he grew visible angry.
“I will tell you what takes away your freedom,” he said. And it’s been the failure of this president to deal, to deal with this virus, and he knew about it.”
During the primary, Biden and his campaign sought to highlight not a ban, but a suspension of leases to frack on federal lands. Even that answer opened up an avenue for Trump to pounce in battleground states like Pennsylvania.
Biden’s answers of late have been even less accommodating. He’s now stressing that he won’t ban the practice until the country finds a path to alternative energies that provides comparable jobs.
“Fracking has to continue because we need a transition, Biden said. “We’re going to get to net-zero emissions by 2050, and we’ll get to net-zero power emissions by 2035. But there’s no rationale to eliminate, right now, fracking.”
Asked whether the Green New Deal, which he doesn’t support, is “too much,” Biden said no. But, “I have my own deal.”
“It requires for us to move in a direction to fundamentally change the way in which we deal with the environment,” pointing to his past work to fund more “renewable energy so it’s now more competitive than it is for coal or for oil or for gas.”
‘Talk about losers’
Biden again seized on the recent story in The Atlantic in which Trump reportedly called soldiers who died in combat “suckers” and “losers” — making for one of his sharpest attacks over the night. (Trump has vociferously denied the story, which was based on the accounts from unnamed sources.)
A woman whose 66-year-old mother was diagnosed with multiple myeloma two years ago asked Biden how he could make health care more affordable.
Biden launched into Trump going to the federal courts to gut the Affordable Care Act. Thinking about those who are sick, Biden began taking about his late son, Beau, who he said returned home after a year in Iraq because he had stage 4 glioblastoma. In the past, Biden has repeatedly referred to Trump as a fool — for his handling of the virus, and also for accusing Biden of taking performance-enhancing drugs. On Thursday, he suggested the president is also a loser.
“The president referred to guys like my son, he won the Bronze Star, the Conspicuous Service Medal, refer[red] to them as losers,” Biden said, his hand chopping the air. “Losers. Talk about losers.”